“Until Dawn” is not a good horror movie. The horror is thematically incoherent (and yes, there’s an in-story excuse for that incoherence, but that doesn’t make it any better). It’s also not a good adaptation of “Until Dawn”—the story and the characters are totally different.
But! It really feels like a horror movie that Supermassive Games would make. It captures their style perfectly. It would fit right into the Dark Pictures anthology.